HancockWritten by Vincent Ngo and Vince Gilligan
Directed by Peter Berg
The Dark KnightWritten/directed by Christopher Nolan
A friend wrote his undergraduate thesis on post-9-11 masculinity in American cinema. He focused on Brokeback Mountain and the Spiderman movies, the normalizing of exhibiting male emotion and what it means to be a hero in a world where evil is ambiguous.
It doesn't take a rocket scientist or an imaginative undergraduate to see that the main characters in Hancock and Dark Knight are not John Wayne. Christian Bale, Heath Ledger, Aaron Eckhart, and Will Smith, lead actors of my generation, embody characters who are flawed, frightening, and broken. These are not our parents' superheroes.
Though not an aficionado of the Batman canon (I dabble), I have seen all the films from Keaton to Kilmer to Clooney. I know all the words to Seal's "Kiss by a Rose" and I once came as Poison Ivy for Halloween. However, I doubt Jim Carrey's Riddler would have fared well in this new Batman narrative. His campy persona, neon jumpsuit and cacophonous giggle would be incongruent in the intensely dark storyline where death is a coin flip away.
Mr. Ledger, whose highly-publicized performance is worth every accolade, is hard to watch on screen. I felt as if I was watching the actor unravel. He takes every risk, manufactures every mannerism. There is no "acting;" there is only who he is. For this reason, it seems like dangerous voyeurism. As for the rest of the film, there are some good performances, some great chase scenes, but it is 45 minutes too long. I also find the character of Bruce Wayne too obnoxious and true to a growing class of entitled i-bankers, oblivious to our precarious economic situation. Count your hedgefunds now, hang onto your shirt soon. Maggie Gyllenhaal is too drab to be so coveted.
Mr. Smith portrays a drunk, volatile superhuman. But unlike Batman, Hancock seemed to have a positive message encouraging personal change for the betterment of all. For once this summer, we had some girl action star power (I won't give too much away) other than Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants 2 (What? Alexis Bledel rides a camel). We also had a great ensemble with Bateman, Theron, and Smith. So why did this film concern me? I saw this film in Europe, where thanks to our flagging currency, a matinee ticket was $22. Forget about coffee at $7. Those horrible chocolate coated ice cream bites: $12! I'll take New York prices thanks.
Let's return to a simpler time at Cupcake Cafe, West 18th in Chelsea. Take a slice of carrot cake with colorful frosting, fruit juice, and a selection from the attached childrens' bookstore. I could go for some Dr. Seuss.