
Style and Sadness
Sex and the City
Written/directed by Michael Patrick King
Midnight in a Manhattan multiplex: mini skirts and Marc Jacobs bags march up the escalator of the Lincoln Square Loews. This is not your typical summer blockbuster crowd (Indy who?), but rather a cultish sorority of millennial mavens. They are gathering to pay homage to the series that taught them how to shop, how to date, and how to live in the city of New York.
As Carrie Bradshaw explained as soon as the clock struck 12:01, these are the twenty-somethings who came to the city in search of "love and labels. " Tonight they are among their friends, real and imagined, wearing stilletos and slip dresses as a sign of solidarity to the sisterhood of Carrie, Charlotte, Samantha and Miranda. Mere teenagers when the show first aired on HBO on their neighbor's rec room television in northern New Jersey, southwestern Ohio, and the mitten of Michigan, these young girls are now young professionals pursuing the life promised by Carrie and co. Certainly their suburban soccer moms didn't teach them to dress or hail a cab like that. Each audience member can identify with one or more of the women (ex."I am a little Charlotte meets Miranda..." or some other combination of the four females). Through that connection, the show has been instrumental in each audience member's urban upbringing. The show was hope in the form of 30 minute serials. You CAN "have it all, it declared--the clothes, the men, the city, the job, the friends.
After I left the movie theatre that night, some of that magic had vanished. While the clothes are still fabulous and the friendships still solid, the society isn't. With age (now the women are pushing or well into their forties) comes a desire for commitment that doesn't seem attainable in our consumer-driven culture. Men shop now too. And the return policy on single girls in this populous city is pretty loose (the principles of supply and demand seem to say hang on to what you've got--see Charlotte and Harry). Watching SATC the movie was like watching the women who raised me beaten down by bad situations and weak scripts: adultery, cold feet, infertility, and monogamy (actually, I don't quite understand the whole Samantha side story). These women are no longer free, they are trapped in a Lifetime movie. Albeit with better clothes.
SATC clocked in at 2.5 hours, too long for a comedy, which this was not. Our glimpse into these womens' lives didn't offer moments of professional success (no Miranda trial lawyer scene), we only got to see the women at their most vulnerable (frail Carrie, dejected Miranda). The superheroine sexpots shrank a little. The world no longer seems like their oyster in the way it is presented to Charlotte's daughter (you can do anything, the white knight is waiting). The women are more real, broken, and less fantastical. Carrie's principal self-reflective narrative (her sex column, a popular motif in the tv show) is absent. This frame story served an important purpose in linking the vignettes into some kind of positive moral. Without this device, we are left to our own devices. We find ourselves in this city that Carrie brought us to and we can't call home.
But here we are, with our friends, our shoes, and our Magnolia Bakery cupcakes (now at 68th and Columbus as well as in the West Village) left to forge our own destiny. Can you have your cupcake and eat it too? Here's hoping.